Электронные письма Бхакти Вайбхавы Свами (Bhaktivaibhava Swami) членам GBC, а также в отдел защиты детей и отдел коммуникаций ISKCON по поводу решения по делу Бхакти Видья Пурны Свами (Bhakti Vidya Purna Swami)

In-Reply-To: <3113761@pamho.net>
MIME-Version: 1.0




Dear GBC members, Pamho. AgtSP!


Sorry for answering so late.


| feel that | have offended some of you, especially Sriman Hari Sauri
prabhu, by wanting to withdraw my pledge to the COP. | wrote a
personal letter to Dhira Govinda prabhu, he and Anuttama prabhu replied
and | sent my response. Perhaps it is Lord Krishna's arrangement that my
letter had been placed on this conference. | am not intending to protest
about it.


| have to admit that | was reacting out of sentiment and nothing more, as
Hari Sauri prabhu stated. | have strong sentiments for anyone who has
taken shelter in Srila Prabhupada's movement. Out of sentiment | have
strong emotional feelings about the torture that has been done to our
children. That's why | want to financially help the COP, although it is not
easy for me, believe me. | am traveling in areas without any financial
support. Siberia, Far East Russia and the Ukraine require aid projects to
help the devotees in the bare necessities of their life. You might think
that for me to pledge $1000.00 is peanuts but | strongly beg to differ. |
understand that this amount is nothing in comparison to what suffering
our children had to experience in the past. | hope that | can organise some
sort of fund-rasing for the CPO soon but as of now | have to collect the
pledge myself.


| also have strong sentiments for the senior devotees in our movements,
especially H.H. Bhaktividya Purna Maharaja who helped me and others
in so many ways. | still consider the agreement between the CPO and
BVP Maharaja to be a punishment on the latter. Although Hari Sauri
prabhu would not agree, | don't want to get into any further details and |
object to the notion that | am incompetent to offer any substance. My
objection is not at all related to the CPO's procedural dealings with BVPS
but rather related to the fact he is being removed from the gurukula in


                    4/24/00    America Online : ljyadasa   Page 4

Mayapur (life-long as | was told), forbidden to lecture in any ISKCON
center, etc. This year in Mayapur | felt very sad and indeed emotional,
having to watch BVPS packing his things and leaving for good. | felt sad
and wrote my letter of protest to Dhira Govinda prabhu that | cannot
financially support such actions. Unless we work out a non-sentiment
system of financial support for the COP, | feel dependent on my own
conviction and inspiration to submit my pledge. | was not aware that |
had to make a brahminical promise of giving my pledge. | thought is was
meant to be voluntary.



| feel already so bad that | will certainly try to give my pledge but it
hurts
me when | am being accused of:


showing sentiment and "nothing more"


being into politics


being part of the old boys club in operation again


having no regard for the innocent boys who suffered like anything


neglecting to clean up the past mistakes of our society


and


attempting to interfer with the CPO's work.


| feel that this assessment of myself is anything else but
                                                                                  encouraging. lf
indeed true, | see it as Lord Krishna's arrangement an
                                                                         d have to work hard
on improving myself in this regard.


Your humble servant                      3
Dasa A.C. Bhaktivaibhava Swami



moana nnn nn nnn -n nn === Headers ---------------------
                                                        -----------
Return-Path: <AC.Bhaktivaibhava.Swam
                                                     i@pamho.net>


                         4/24/00             America Online : ljyadasa
                                                                         Page 5

Subj:     BVPM
Date:     Friday, April 21, 2000 12
                                   :56:57 PM
From:     Dgovinda
To:       hanuman.das@bbt.se, PMD5@
                                           hotmail.com,
          Dasarath@compuserve.com, ljyadas
                                                   a




Dear Anuttama prabhu, Pamho.
                                  AgtSP!

sorry to answer so late. | just
                                  returned and ran into a lot of meetings and
other arrangments.


>| am naturally disappointed that yo
                                       u changed your mind.

That's what | naturally expected. | mentioned it.
                                                           | feel the same, and | am
asking to give some consideration for my dis
                                                   appointment.

 >| hope that you will reconsider your decision in light
                                                               of the need to help
 >our youth, as well as the need to demonstrate to the
                                                               youth that the GBC
 >leaders consider their welfare as a priority.


 | understand the need to help our youth, that's why | am trying to
                                                                            give my
 fiancial contributions. At the same time it is not easy for me to do so
 since | am working in an area where devotees and projects require
                                                                             help as
 well, not only finacially, but in so many other ways too. | mentioned
                                                                               that
 | am being more and more taxed for various projects and needs. At the
 Same time there is no global consideration for the demanding
 expenditures | have as a GBC member. | have to set my priorities.
 However, | will try my best to contribute as much as possible for me. It
 might not be the entire amount.


 >You might also consider that we can easily designate that your donation
 >will go directly to aid a victim of abuse, and not for OCP general
 >expenses, etc.



 | trust your good sense of discrimination. This is not the problem.
                                                                             The
 problem is my own disappointment and my own financial situation.


                   4/24/00     America Online : ljyadasa       Page 1

 Financial commitment came up after | made my pledge for the CPO.

 >As | understand the situation, the agreement that was reached with the
 >Maharaja was done in part to prevent him from being uneccessarily
 >embarassed by the details of the case. As difficult as the penance he
 >agreed to undergo may be, it was handled in a way that he would not
 >have all of the details of his alledged personal (physical) abuse of
 >children as well as his failure to respond to reported sexual abuse (by
 >others) made public.


 My underst   an din g is  th at  the  re  ha  s be   en  alr ea dy an   inv es tig ati on    in  19  91
 and as a result BVP Sw        am  i wa  nte  d  to    res ign  fro m   re sp on  sib ilit ies . Th  e
 local GBC requeste    d   him  to   co nti nu  e.   He  acc ep  ted  and   car rie d  on   . No w
 he is be ing  pu nis he d  for  it. | do  n't  wa   nt to   ge t int o  an y fur  the  r  de  tai ls.
 Others have more      inf or ma   tio n's  an d   | am   su re  that  th e  ca se  do   es   no t  re st
 at the present decision by the CPO.

>Perhaps you rem em ber the de scr ipt ion of tea ch ers pa ssi ng sem en on
>maha prasada and the n ha vin g bo ys be for ce d to ea t it? Th at oc cu rre d
>under his authority as director of the school.

Why is only he held re po ns ibl e? Wh y no t the loc al GB C's to o. Th ey are
as responible for such an impo rtant pr oje ct as he is. | wa nt to see so m e
balance in light of     his   ou  tstan din  g   service   he   ha s  ren  de  red  ov er  the  ma  ny
years. He   ce rta inl y is   res  po ns ibl e  for  th os e  ho  rri ble  cri me  s bu  t wh  at
abou t th e m an y  go  od  th  ing s  he  ha  s  done . Is  th is no  t  ta ke n int o
consideration.   Ag  ain ,  |  do  n't wa  nt   to  un ne ces  sar  ily  exp  en d  on  thi s po int .
There wil l be  as se ssm   en   t rep  or ts  pr ep are d  by   oth   ers  wh  o  kn ow   th e
M ah ar aj a's se rv ice in the Gu rukula better th an m e.                     |

>Re gar din g the tes ts tha t alle ged abu ser s ma y hav e to und erg o, wh eth er
>they be sanyasis, grhastras, brahmacaris or whatever, | would strongly
>argue that the amount of discomfort a man may have to undergo during
>these tests is far, far overweighed by the importance of uncovering
>sexual abuse andprotecting our youth.

| agree in case there is sufficient evidence for abuse. Otherwise, |
strongly disagree. You have to respect the moral rights of a sannyasi. To
                       4/24/00          America Online : ljyadasa          Page 2

         abuse a child is a crime and to abuse a Sannyasi is a crime
                                                                          as well
         according to sastra. | certainly agree with the need to pro
                                                                         tect our
         children
         but at the same time | expect a sense of integrity in the replies of the
         COP
         related to questions concerning senior God brothers.


         >Let us remember that many, many sanyasis (and others) in the past

         >HAVE engaged in horrible, destructive behavior while in the dress of a
         >Sanyasi. Therefore, we must be vigilent to not overlook serious
          >allegations against an alleged abuser simply because its uncomfortable
          >for them to answer questions that might reveal deviant mental states.


          It seems that you are fixed on your particular point of view and
          understanding and that is needed for accomplishing the mission of the
          COP. However, | expected more understanding and concern for the
          particluar points | addressed. | don't see the need of trying to convince
          me about the fundamental and general purpose of the COP.


          Your humble servant
          Dasa A.C. Bhaktivaibhava Swami



          eee Hoaders(-__—_--—
   ? Return-Path: <AC.Bhaktivaibhava.Swami@pamho.net>
Ne Received: from rly-yg03.mx.aol.com (rly-yg03.mail.aol.com [172.18.147.3]) by air-
  i 4ms paralaol.com (v70.20) with ESMTP; Mon, 17 Apr 2000 10:58:00 2000
    ee sheceive
           ,   d:from comservert.jos.net ([212.116.77.42]) by rly-yg03.mx.aol.com (v71.10)

                    MI" >; Mon,17 Apr 2000 10:57:33 -0400   .
                 ed: y eae-net(COM a 70.Ueoan 16 Apr 2000 125 50: 03 +0200
                         vaktivai ava‘Swami"<AC.B
                            tiv:asibhava. Sw